How to Order Butterbeer at Starbucks (Plus Recipes!)

Butterbeer Starbucks recipe

No Need to Go to Hogsmeade for Butterbeer

And just like that, everyone in the muggle world is clamoring for some butterbeer. It isn’t exactly how you hope it will be, but then, no one really knows what butterbeer tastes like! Except perhaps, a few fanatics who are still clinging on to Harry Potter, especially in the land of Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, where butterbeer’s recipe has been tried and tested five recipes and protected by no other than J.K. Rowling herself. It’s classified information, top secret! (Though it looks like Sherbert Cafe has debunked the recipe using A&W Cream Soda. Scroll at the end of this post to get the recipe and try it at home. *wink*)

But for us who just want butterbeer on a regular day basis (though we don’t really what it tastes like), there’s always Starbucks, the brand that’s just around the corner. And they have their own version of butterbeer.

“Less-Sickly Butterscotch”

The popular wizarding beverage was described as “a little bit like less-sickly butterscotch” with some alcoholic content that’s enough to make house elves drunk and keep Dumbledore’s palette refreshing. It’s supposed to be smooth when it goes down your throat. So, does Starbucks’ version of butterbeer get it right? I went to the nearest Starbucks to check it out.

How to Order Butterbeer at Starbucks

At the counter, I was hesitant whether to tell them it’s butterbeer I want to order. But since the baristas are probably accustomed to screaming Harry Potter fans, I simply told them, “I’d like to get a tall Hot butterbeer please.” Yes, I was that bold and thankfully they understood, asking me if I wanted cream-based or coffee-based, opting for the latter instead.

Butterbeer Starbucks recipe

Boy for a drink that’s supposed to cost only 2 sickles in the wizarding world, this ain’t cheap especially if it’s your everyday brew. Perhaps being a muggle comes at a price, eh?

Turns out it’s just Salted Caramel Mocha plus additional syrup since it’s Christmas season. Although I had a different recipe in mind, which I got from E!Online. (Though there are many versions of this)

Butterbeer Starbucks recipe

Recipe for Starbucks’ Butterbeer Frappuccino:

Regular Creme Frappucino
3 pumps of Caramel Syrup
3 pumps of Toffee Nut Syrup
Salted Caramel Drizzle on top

Recipe for Starbucks’ Butterbeer Latte (Hot):

Whole milk steamer
2 pumps of Caramel Syrup
2 pumps of Toffee Nut Syrup
2 pumps of Cinnamon Dolce Syrup
Whipped cream
Salted Caramel Drizzle on top
Optional: Add a shot of espresso

First taste: it’s salty. Very salty. And the first gulp going down my throat was just sticky. I feel like I was drowning in caramel. But the flavor is extremely rich I was torn between the whip cream’s cool creamy texture and the strong coffee that’s fighting its way between the cream. And the beverage wasn’t that hot to keep it down.

Succeeding gulps? Surprisingly, it went well, as if my throat was finally adjusted to the extremely sweet drink. Although the sugar sank at the bottom and it was too sweet for me. There was a hint of alcohol tangy taste left behind which is just right.

Would I drink this everyday? Absolutely not! This is bound to make anyone pre-diabetes.

Butterbeer Starbucks Recipe

One thing’s for sure, it isn’t refreshing as what Dumbledore said. Quoting the New York Observer, “it’s just two pumps of disappointment.” After all, I don’t recall butterbeer being a type of coffee drink in the Harry Potter series.

As promised earlier, here’s Sherbert Cafe’s recipe of homemade butterbeer inspired by the drink that is sold at Universal Studios. Perhaps it’s a better alternative than dropping by Starbucks.

Homemade Butterbeer Recipe (taken from Sherbert Cafe):

1 Big Bowl
2 2-Liter Bottles of A&W Cream Soda
1 Jar of Butterscotch Topping
1 Tub of Cool Whip
The some Light Karo Syrup
and a little Rum Extract

1. In large bowl dump 1 bottle for Cream Soda and stir in about 1/2 – 3/4 Cup of Butterscotch Topping.
2. Stir that slowly till slightly blended and then place the whole bowl in the freezer. 3. Stir it every half hour
4. Open up your tub of Cool Whip.
5. Add 3 tablespoons of Butterscotch Topping
6. Add 2 Tablespoons Light Karo Syrup
7. Add 1 Teaspoon Rum Extract
8. Whip until it’s well-blended
9. Place the lid back on and stick it in the fridge to await your frozen Butterbeer.
10. To serve you will want to chop up your froze stuff from the freezer and fill your cup lightly about 3/4 the way full with the slush.
11. Then pour some cream soda from the none frozen bottle, over the the stuff until your slush is at least covered.
12. Plop a heavy spoonful of the Froth over the top. It seems to expand a little as time goes by.

DIY Affogato

Butterbeer aside, I’d rather have my own DIY affogato. Just get any black brewed coffee and toss McDonald’s vanilla sundae on it. You can share 1 serving of sundae with a friend. And it’s perfect for me. Top it with some brown sugar and you have the cheapest affogato to fix your everyday brew.